Blog / Civil Rights

Expanded Legislation in Wrongful Conviction Leads to Exonerees’ Justice

November 10, 2020

Imagine spending eleven years in prison for a heinous crime you didn’t commit—eleven years away from family, not completing your college degree or advancing your career, and putting your life on hold. Then imagine the state exonerates you but refuses to compensate you for wrongful conviction. 

This was the reality Mary Jenny Wilcox (now Reach) and Robert “Bobby” Aldridge faced when they were wrongfully convicted of child molestation in 1985. They were exonerated and released in 1996 but had to wait until 2020 (twenty-four years after their release) for the state to compensate them for wrongful imprisonment.

Jenny and Bobby were wrongfully charged and convicted of operating “sexual experimentation” on a group of children living in their apartment complex. Their case was appealed and successfully overturned after an investigation uncovered exculpatory information had been withheld from their defense counsel. It turned out that the children’s statements were coerced. When they were adults, the children recanted their testimonies. 

Wrongful Conviction Compensation Statute

The State of Ohio amended the Wrongful Conviction Compensation statute in March 2019, which expanded the number of exonerees eligible for compensation. Because the statute is retroactive, it allows individuals whose convictions were overturned many years ago to file another claim. 

The amendment also expanded avenues through which exonerees can prove they were wrongfully convicted such as “Brady violations”— instances in which police or prosecutors withhold exculpatory information from the defense. Because of this statute’s amendment, Jenny and Bobby were eligible to appeal for compensation decades later even though they had previously filed an unsuccessful wrongful conviction claim.

Jenny and Bobby came to Cooper Elliot for help in 2019. The very next year, we achieved a sizeable payout for their years of hardship.

Exoneration and Compensation Leads to Healing

During her wrongful imprisonment, Jenny was denied the opportunity to raise her two young children and was forced to delay earning her college degree. Although she will never get those eleven years back, she rebuilt the relationship with her children and is now a social worker thanks to the healing and financial support achieved through the settlement we sought from the state.

Bobby’s life and career were also put on hold, but as a father of four and grandfather of nine, he rests easier knowing justice prevailed. 

Wrongful convictions and wrongful imprisonment affect every aspect of an exoneree’s life—strained relationships with loved ones, prejudice, and stigma after rightful release, missed career and financial opportunities, and mental and emotional anguish. 

Cooper Elliott attorneys thoroughly investigate backgrounds and contexts of potential cases and advises exonerees about their rights. When we take on a wrongful conviction case, we care about the people involved and how the case affects all aspects of their lives.

Give us a call—we’re here to help.

The outcome of any client’s case will depend on the particular legal and factual circumstances of the case.

Latest Blog Posts

October 1, 2020

The Importance of Seeking Legal Representation for Hazing Incidents

Unfortunately, hazing is far too common and often excused as “tradition.”  It impacts victims and their families in many ways. When it results in injury or death, seeking trustworthy legal advice and conducting a full investigation is critical. Every time a perpetrator is held accountable, we take a step towards changing society’s perception of hazing.  …

Continue reading “The Importance of Seeking Legal Representation for Hazing Incidents”

August 6, 2020

Act Now Before Sub. H.B. 606 COVID-19 Immunity Legislation Passes

Amidst the chaos of 2020, COVID-19 immunity legislation quietly proceeds through the Ohio legislature. If Sub. H.B. 606 passes and is signed into law, it will provide broad immunity to healthcare workers who committed malpractice from March 9, 2020 through December 31, 2020.  Sub. H.B. 606 Sub. H.B. 606 would give immunity to doctors and …

Continue reading “Act Now Before Sub. H.B. 606 COVID-19 Immunity Legislation Passes”

July 30, 2020

Scouting-Abuse Claims Require Immediate Attention

A child enrolls in Boy Scouts of America and proudly moves through the ranks. Each craft, each outing builds his character, and he’s so pleased with his progress—until the unimaginable happens. Whether overnight or perhaps over time, the abuse or molestation committed by a scout leader comes to light, as it did in this recent …

Continue reading “Scouting-Abuse Claims Require Immediate Attention”